Today is National Key Lime Pie Day, celebrating the sweet-tart Florida favorite made with Key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk and egg yolks.
Key limes are smaller, more fragrant and more tart than the Persian limes most grocery stores carry. The pie’s exact origin is still debated, but recipes were showing up in Florida by the 1930s, when canned condensed milk made the creamy filling easy to make without fresh dairy. One easy way to spot the real thing: Key lime pie should be pale yellow, not green. Early versions were topped with meringue, while whipped cream became common later.
To celebrate with homemade Key lime pie, Sally’s Baking gives the classic a little upgrade with a graham cracker-macadamia nut crust, fills it with Key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk and egg yolks, then bakes it briefly before chilling until creamy and sliceable.
